Easter closure

Please note that we will be closed from 5pm Thursday 28 March until Tuesday 2 April 2024 for the Easter break. Complaints can still be made via our complaints form but they will not be received until we reopen. Wishing you a happy Easter! 

Technical issues:

The SPSO advice line is currently unavailable due to technical issues which we are working with our telephone provider to resolve.  We apologise for the inconvenience and hope to find a resolution as soon as possible. 

Decision report 201202549

  • Case ref:
    201202549
  • Date:
    April 2013
  • Body:
    A Dentist in the Fife NHS Board area
  • Sector:
    Health
  • Outcome:
    Not upheld, no recommendations
  • Subject:
    communication, staff attitude, dignity, confidentiality

Summary

Miss C complained that during treatment a dentist handled her five-year-old daughter (Miss A) with excessive force, and shouted at her. While the dentist was attempting to fill one of Miss A's teeth, she became distressed and moved in the chair. In trying to adjust Miss A's position in the chair, Miss C complained that the dentist handled Miss A roughly, causing bruising to her arm.

The dentist indicated that, as Miss A had slid down the chair, he lifted her under the arms to put her back in the correct position. He said he did not use any force and he could not understand the bruising allegation. He also said that he was required to raise his voice to give instructions to his nurse and be heard over Miss A's crying. He said he did not shout at Miss A. In investigating the complaint, we obtained a statement from the nurse which supported the dentist's position. In the absence of any evidence to support Miss C's version of events, we did not uphold the complaint.

Updated: March 13, 2018