Office closure 

We will be closed on Monday 5 May 2025 for the public holiday.  You can still submit complaints via our online form but we will not respond until we reopen.

New Customer Service Standards

We have updated our Customer Service Standards and are looking for feedback from customers. Please fill out our survey here by 12 May 2025: https://forms.office.com/e/ZDpjibqe8r 

Investigation Report 200904350

  • Report no:
    200904350
  • Date:
    May 2011
  • Body:
    Forth Valley NHS Board
  • Sector:
    Health

Overview
The complainant (Mrs C) raised a number of concerns about the care and treatment provided to her husband (Mr C) by Forth Valley NHS Board (the Board) at Stirling Royal Infirmary (the Hospital) from 3 April 2006 until his death on 27 July 2006. Mrs C also raised concerns about the way in which the Board handled her complaint.

Specific complaints and conclusions
The complaints which have been investigated are that:

  • (a) the Consultant's actions denied Mr C the opportunity to make informed choices about treatment and end of life care and the Board failed to follow the Liverpool Care Pathway (upheld);
  • (b) the Board failed to acknowledge the failings of the Consultant or to make changes or improvements to address the failings (upheld); (c) there was an unnecessary and lengthy delay in the Board's handling of the complaint (upheld);
  • (d) the notes taken at a meeting with the Board's representatives did not fully and accurately detail the depth of Mrs C's concerns and the outcome she wished to achieve (upheld); and
  • (e) Mrs C's request for a meeting with the Consultant was refused unreasonably (not upheld).

 

Redress and recommendations
The Ombudsman recommends that the Board:

  • (i) undertake an external peer review in the Hospital, to include: • the procedures relating to the management of biopsies, including communicating biopsy results; the current strategy for the policy of Living and Dying Well, with particular reference to the implementation of the Liverpool Care Pathway and the role of consultants; the education and training of staff, particularly consultants, relating to end of life care;
  • (ii) ensure that the failings identified in this report are raised with the Consultant during his next appraisal, to ensure lessons have been learned from this case;
  • (iii) provide evidence about how feedback from complaints is used as part of the consultant appraisal process;
  • (iv) review their procedures to ensure they investigate complaints fully, in accordance with the NHS Complaints Procedure, with particular reference to timescales; and
  • (v) apologise to Mrs C for the failures identified in this report.

 

The Board have accepted the recommendations and will act on them accordingly.

Updated: December 11, 2018